[OPINION] We Will Not Give Up On Gun Control

by Rabbi Eric Yoffie

Our leaders have failed us, again. And I don’t know about you, but as a religious person, I’m angry.

Approximately 90 percent of the American people believe that their fellow Americans should undergo a background check before they are permitted to purchase a gun. But the legislation mandating those background checks has been blocked in the Senate. A total of 46 Senators could think of no reason why they should listen to a mere 90 percent of the American people. They could think of no good reason to heed those grieving parents whose children were slaughtered in Newtown or to pay attention to the distraught relatives of so many other victims of gun violence.

If I thought the Senators responsible were acting out of true conviction or real allegiance to the Constitution, perhaps I would feel better. But I don’t believe it.

What I believe is that these politicians were bowing to the power of money and to the lying ads of a ferocious, well-financed and fanatic lobby. I believe that their my-soul-is-for-sale mentality prevented them from seeing what virtually all American can see: Preventing crazies and criminals from getting their hands on a terrifying array of weapons violates no Constitutional principle and in fact is essential for the “domestic tranquility” that our Constitution assures.

And I am especially offended by their “slippery slope” arguments to justify their actions. The “slippery slope” they talk about is no such thing. It is moral sophistry, an effort to put an ethical veneer on what is really moral cowardice and electoral self-interest of the narrowest sort.

Those of us in the religious world know that “slippery slopes” do exist. Morality, after all, is a complicated business, requiring careful thought and appropriate safeguards and protections. As normally used in the moral realm, the term applies to small transgressions that should be avoided because they will otherwise lead to major transgressions. But background checks are not a transgression at all; they are a positive good, intended to safeguard rights guaranteed by the Constitution. Perhaps it is too much to expect moral courage from our representatives in Washington. But is it too much to expect a modicum of common decency and common sense?

The religious community in America has a very, very difficult task at this moment, but this task is enormously important precisely for that reason. The natural thing to happen now would be for Americans to fall prey to cynicism, indifference and dismay. They are disgusted to see American kids dying ugly, public deaths, shot down in the streets and the schools; and they are distraught to witness yet another example of a well-financed, single issue minority throwing around its weight and overriding the will of the majority.

But in this climate, when the gun fanatics are intent on depleting us as a nation and robbing us of our ability to make a difference, leaders of the Abrahamic faith traditions can do what others cannot.

Firm in their belief that human life is sacred, that right is distinct from might and that justice is a supreme value, they can call on Americans not to give up on background checks and other sensible restrictions on guns.

And conscious of the fact that the tobacco lobby was once thought invincible, they can urge Americans not to despair.

And knowing that humanity, though corrupt, is redeemable, they can remind Americans that when it comes to the scourge of gun violence, this is not the time to abandon ship. No gun should be sold without a background check. No exceptions, so help us God. And to those who think otherwise, happy to let the deranged and the misfits run amok with lethal weapons, we say: We vote, we will remember, and we will hold you accountable.

This article was originally published in Huffington Post on April 18, 2013. Rabbi Eric Yoffie is a resident of Westfield who retired in December 2011, after almost 16 years as president of the Union for Reform Judaism, the largest Jewish movement in North America. 

Connect with NJTODAY.NET

Join NJTODAY.NET's free Email List to receive occasional updates delivered right to your email address!
Email ads@njtoday.net for advertising information Send stuff to NJTODAY.NET Like Us On Facebook Follow Us On Twitter Download this week's issue of NJTODAY.NET

4 comments for “[OPINION] We Will Not Give Up On Gun Control

  1. stevea526
    June 3, 2013 at 2:00 pm

    The fact that the overwhelming majority of these horrendous massacres have been caused by folks with no documented evidence of mental behavior or by folks who acquire their weapons from indirect sources (stolen, straw purchases, relatives) means that background checks are nothing but a feel good solution for those who fear guns…for any reason.

  2. Sota War
    May 30, 2013 at 2:24 pm

    Those of us who believe in the Constitution, the 2nd Amendment, the right to personal defense, and in taking responsiblity for our own and our loved ones safety will never stop either.

  3. May 12, 2013 at 6:56 pm

    What a shit article, your opinion means jack. Also, when you bring up 90% of Americans its not 90% of Americans. You must not understand how surveys work and you need to know that, no, over 270 million Americans were not involved. Your welcome.

  4. Anonymous
    April 29, 2013 at 10:12 am

    You’ll never give up on gun control? Well, we’ll never give up defending the right, and we’ll always convince more people, persuade more politicians, march more marches, and put more money and resources into our fight, everytime.

Leave a Reply